Newzly.net

world·Arizona·Pima County

Arizona's RJ Godfrey Adds NCAA to Amended Eligibility Lawsuit

Following an NCAA refusal that kept him sidelined against UConn, Arizona forward RJ Godfrey has amended his Pima County lawsuit to add the association as a defendant, seeking an immediate ruling to play.

3 min readvia Google News Arizona
AI-generated news clip from this story — Arizona Wildcats forward RJ Godfrey during a college basketball matchup

In this piece

Arizona Wildcats forward RJ Godfrey has filed an amended eligibility complaint in Pima County Superior Court, naming the NCAA as a co-defendant. The move comes…

Attorneys representing University of Arizona forward RJ Godfrey have filed an amended eligibility lawsuit in Pima County Superior Court, officially naming the NCAA as a co-defendant. The updated filing seeks an immediate temporary restraining order to compel the collegiate governing body to certify the senior forward for competition.

The decision to add the NCAA directly follows a frustrating setback that sidelined Godfrey during Arizona’s high-profile clash against the UConn Huskies. Although a local state judge had previously ruled that the university could clear Godfrey to play, the NCAA declined to recognize the ruling, asserting that it was not bound by orders issued in a case where it was not named as a party.

Godfrey’s legal team initially pursued a novel strategy by filing a breach-of-contract lawsuit against the University of Arizona and the Arizona Board of Regents rather than suing the NCAA. That action argued that the university was contractually obligated under NCAA bylaws to certify Godfrey for a fifth season of college basketball eligibility, bypassing the NCAA’s central enforcement apparatus.

In that initial proceeding, Pima County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Bergin sided with Godfrey, granting both a temporary restraining order and a preliminary injunction. Judge Bergin interpreted NCAA Bylaw 12.6 as an enforceable agreement between the association and member institutions, finding that the text lacked an explicit written exclusion barring eligibility for athletes who graduated high school in 2022.

Despite that ruling, the NCAA refused to budge, leaving the university caught between conflicting legal obligations and the threat of NCAA sanctions. In response to Godfrey being withheld from the UConn game, his attorneys filed contempt motions and subsequently restructured the complaint to pull the Indianapolis-based association directly into the Pima County courtroom.

The Pima County action represents the latest phase of an extensive multi-state legal campaign mounted by Godfrey to secure his final collegiate season. The Clemson transfer previously joined a federal antitrust complaint in Georgia, where an initial temporary restraining order was paused by an appellate court, before briefly pursuing a separate challenge in Texas that was dismissed on jurisdictional grounds.

At the center of Godfrey's legal battle is the interpretation of the NCAA’s five-year eligibility window and how exceptions apply to players whose high school careers overlapped with pandemic disruptions. Godfrey and his attorneys maintain that student-athletes from the 2022 graduating class are entitled to an additional competitive season under the spirit and language of revised collegiate sports governance rules.

The dispute arrives amid a broader wave of athlete-led litigation challenging the NCAA's traditional authority over transfer restrictions, eligibility limits, and athlete compensation. Across the country, courts have increasingly scrutinized and dismantled longstanding NCAA bylaws, leaving conferences and athletic departments navigating an unpredictable legal environment.

With the NCAA now formally named as a defendant, the Pima County court is expected to schedule an expedited hearing on Godfrey’s request for immediate injunctive relief. Arizona’s coaching staff and compliance officials are monitoring the docket closely, hoping to resolve the forward’s status ahead of the Wildcats’ upcoming tournament games at the Maui Invitational.

Whether the state court's jurisdiction will withstand an anticipated federal removal or jurisdictional challenge from the NCAA remains an open question for sports law observers. For Godfrey, however, the amended complaint represents a decisive push to turn a prolonged courtroom odyssey into minutes on the hardwood before his collegiate career concludes.

Primary source: Google News Arizona. Newzly rewrites and structures source reporting for clarity; verify critical details at the original.