Tether Invokes 'The Big Short' in Swipe at S&P Over Stablecoin Reserve Warning
Tether pushed back against S&P Global Ratings after the agency held USDT at its lowest stability score, invoking 'The Big Short' to argue traditional Wall Street frameworks fail to understand crypto reserves.

In this piece
Tether has criticized S&P Global Ratings over an evaluation that kept USDT at the lowest stability score of 5 due to volatile reserve holdings. The stablecoin…
Tether has fiercely rejected an updated risk assessment from S&P Global Ratings, citing the 2008 financial crisis drama "The Big Short" to criticize traditional credit rating methodologies. The ratings agency maintained its stability assessment for the flagship USDT stablecoin at 5, the lowest tier on its evaluation scale, citing an elevated proportion of higher-risk assets backing the token.
According to S&P Global Ratings, alternative and volatile holdings in Tether's reserves grew to represent 28 percent of USDT's circulating backing as of September 30, up from 24 percent a year earlier. The agency cautioned that significant exposure to assets such as Bitcoin, gold, corporate bonds, public equities, and secured loans creates substantial collateral risk. A severe downturn across these volatile assets could potentially leave the stablecoin undercollateralized, the agency warned.
S&P Global explained that it did not downgrade USDT further solely because a score of 5 is already the lowest available mark in its Stablecoin Stability Assessment framework. The evaluation examines both the creditworthiness and liquidity of backing collateral alongside operational and regulatory safeguards. Despite noting compounded structural vulnerabilities, the framework had no lower numeric tier to assign to the digital dollar issuer.
In response to the assessment, Tether dismissed S&P's conclusions as a symptom of outdated Wall Street analytical models. The company stated that the issue lies in S&P's framework rather than its underlying reserves, arguing that traditional agencies have historically miscalculated systemic financial risks. Tether invoked "The Big Short" to underscore what it characterized as persistent institutional blind spots that previously led legacy rating agencies to overlook risks prior to the 2008 subprime mortgage collapse.
To defend its solvency, Tether pointed to its third-quarter reserve attestation completed by accounting firm BDO. The September 30 filing reported total assets of approximately $191.5 billion set against roughly $183.5 billion in liabilities, yielding a capital cushion of about $7.95 billion in excess reserves. Company representatives emphasized that this surplus capital absorbs asset volatility and protects token holders from potential market shocks.
Beyond reserve composition, S&P Global highlighted broader governance and jurisdictional challenges facing the world's largest stablecoin operator. The agency raised concerns regarding Tether's regulatory footing following its corporate relocation to El Salvador, alongside the absence of strict statutory mandates governing asset segregation. S&P also noted the ongoing lack of a comprehensive public financial audit by a Big Four accounting firm, which continues to differentiate Tether from regulated institutional peers.
The disagreement highlights an enduring debate across global financial markets over how to measure risk in the burgeoning digital asset sector. USDT remains the primary liquidity bridge in cryptocurrency trading and international cross-border settlements, boasting a circulation exceeding $180 billion. Financial regulators and institutional counterparties increasingly scrutinize stablecoin backing, arguing that reserve illiquidity or collateral impairment could spill over into broader credit channels.
The clash also illustrates divergent philosophies between decentralized finance advocates and traditional rating houses. While rating agencies prioritize strict cash equivalents and short-dated government securities, crypto-native issuers like Tether have steadily allocated surplus capital toward physical gold and Bitcoin to hedge against fiat currency devaluation. This diversification strategy has delivered record operating profits for Tether, even as legacy analysts view it as an unnecessary risk to capital preservation.
Looking ahead, scrutiny over stablecoin reserve composition is expected to intensify as major jurisdictions implement formal oversight frameworks, including the European Union's Markets in Crypto-Assets regulation and pending federal legislation in the United States. While Tether maintains that its substantial equity surplus and liquid Treasury portfolio provide adequate protection, rating agencies are likely to maintain conservative scores until full financial audits and ring-fenced reserve structures are implemented.
Primary source: CoinTelegraph. Newzly rewrites and structures source reporting for clarity; verify critical details at the original.