world·Alaska·Matanuska-Susitna Borough
Two Alaska Legislative Races Within Five Votes After Ranked-Choice Tabulations
Ranked-choice voting tabulations in Alaska have left two Matanuska-Susitna legislative races separated by four votes or fewer, triggering prospective recounts that could reshape coalition dynamics in the state House.
In this piece
Two Alaska House races in the Matanuska-Susitna Borough sit within five votes following ranked-choice tabulations by state election officials. Republican…
Two closely watched legislative races in Alaska remained virtually tied within five votes following ranked-choice voting tabulations conducted by the Alaska Division of Elections. In House District 30, Republican challenger Doug Massie holds an extraordinarily narrow three-vote lead over incumbent Republican Representative Kevin McCabe. Meanwhile, in neighboring House District 29, incumbent Republican Representative Garret Nelson leads challenger Steve Menard by just four votes.
The outcome in House District 30, which encompasses portions of the western Matanuska-Susitna Borough and the Denali Borough, shifted after voters' second- and third-choice preferences were redistributed. After the final round of ranked-choice calculations, Massie stood at 3,195 votes compared to 3,192 for McCabe. The micro-margin highlights how lower-tier candidate eliminations can dramatically swing competitive intraparty showdowns under Alaska's election model.
In District 29, also located in the Matanuska-Susitna Borough, the final tabulation revealed an equally razor-thin outcome between the two Republican contenders. Nelson finished the tabulation round with 3,135 votes, edging out Menard, who collected 3,131 votes. As in District 30, reallocation of ballots from eliminated minor candidates proved decisive in bringing the contenders into an effective deadlock.
Alaska utilizes a top-four open primary system followed by ranked-choice voting in general elections, adopted by voters in 2020. Under this system, if no candidate secures an outright majority of first-choice votes, the lowest-ranking candidates are systematically eliminated. Ballots cast for those eliminated candidates are then transferred to the voters' subsequent preferences until one candidate crosses the winning threshold.
Both contests pitted conservative incumbents against intraparty challengers in Alaska's fast-growing Matanuska-Susitna Borough, a traditionally conservative heartland of the state. Because multiple candidates from the same party routinely advance to the general ballot, voters frequently decide between competing factions of the Republican coalition. These specific match-ups showcased deep localized divisions over policy priorities and legislative representation.
The razor-thin margins in both districts carry significant ramifications for the balance of power and coalition-building in the 40-member Alaska House of Representatives. In recent legislative sessions, control of the House has hinged on fragile bipartisan coalitions and narrow single-seat majorities. Even a single vote shift that changes an incumbent's status can alter committee assignments, caucus alignments, and leadership negotiations in Juneau.
Election officials have emphasized that the figures released during the ranked-choice tabulation process remain unofficial until final certification. The Division of Elections continues to account for late-arriving absentee, questioned, and overseas military ballots that were postmarked on or before Election Day. In contests decided by margins of three and four votes, any newly eligible ballot could alter the final standings.
Given the microscopic vote differentials, both races are virtually certain to qualify for state-funded recounts under Alaska election law. Under statutory guidelines, candidates in legislative races separated by extremely narrow margins or fractions of a percent can request an automatic or state-sponsored recount. Candidates and campaigns are preparing for intense scrutiny of individual challenged ballots before official certification.
The Alaska State Review Board will oversee the formal canvass and review of remaining precinct materials over the coming days ahead of target certification deadlines. Once official results are formally certified by state election authorities, campaigns will have the statutory window to petition for administrative recounts or pursue judicial remedies. Until those formal proceedings conclude, representation for both Mat-Su districts hangs on a handful of uncertified ballots.
Primary source: Google News Alaska. Newzly rewrites and structures source reporting for clarity; verify critical details at the original.