Newzly.net

world·Colorado·Denver County

Colorado Republicans Sue to Block Voter-Approved Amendment 87 Tax Hikes

Republican lawmakers and conservative advocates have filed a lawsuit in Denver District Court to block Colorado's voter-approved Amendment 87, challenging its shift from a flat income tax to a graduated system.

2 min readvia Google News Colorado
AI-generated news clip from this story — The Colorado State Capitol building in Denver under a clear blue sky

In this piece

Colorado Republican state senators and Advance Colorado have filed a lawsuit to invalidate Amendment 87, a newly passed measure that replaces the state's flat…

Colorado Republican lawmakers and conservative advocacy leaders have filed a lawsuit seeking to block Amendment 87 from taking effect, challenging the newly approved ballot measure in Denver District Court. The complaint, brought on behalf of state Senators Barbara Kirkmeyer and Byron Pelton with backing from the conservative advocacy group Advance Colorado, aims to halt the landmark tax restructuring before state revenue officials can implement it.

Passed narrowly by Colorado voters, Amendment 87 repeals the state's longstanding flat income tax rate of 4.4 percent and establishes a graduated bracket structure. Under the approved framework, higher-earning households and businesses reporting income above $500,000 face increased tax rates, while lower- and middle-income residents receive modest rate reductions.

State fiscal estimates indicate that the overhaul could generate approximately $2 billion annually in new state revenue. Proponents campaigned heavily on using the proceeds to deliver dedicated funding streams for Colorado public education, expanded healthcare access, and subsidized childcare services across the state.

At the center of the Republican legal challenge is Colorado’s Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights, known as TABOR, which tightly regulates how state taxes and constitutional amendments are presented to voters. The plaintiffs contend that Amendment 87 improperly bundled two distinct legal questions into a single initiative by simultaneously repealing the constitutional flat-tax mandate and enacting statutory tiered tax rates.

According to the complaint, combining constitutional changes with statutory adjustments violates TABOR provisions designed to ensure voters evaluate separate tax mechanisms independently. The lawmakers argue that organizers should have submitted two individual ballot questions, giving voters the opportunity to decide on the constitutional mandate separate from the specific bracket structure.

The lawsuit further alleges that proponents circulated flawed fiscal projections and misleading calculations during the campaign. Plaintiffs claim that errors in the methodology underestimated obligations for certain business owners and high earners, resulting in situations where taxpayers initially told they would see relief could instead experience unexpected tax hikes.

Supporters of Amendment 87, including a broad coalition of progressive policy organizations and education advocates, have firmly defended the measure's legitimacy. They emphasize that the initiative successfully navigated rigorous pre-election reviews, including required approvals from the Colorado Title Board and surviving legal scrutiny before the Colorado Supreme Court prior to reaching the ballot.

The lawsuit represents the latest chapter in Colorado's decades-long battle over TABOR and the limits of state fiscal authority. Progressive groups have long argued that the flat tax constrains public investment in critical infrastructure and schools, while conservative leaders maintain that strict constitutional caps protect residents and businesses from burdensome taxation.

The legal fight will now proceed through Denver District Court, where judges are expected to weigh requests for injunctive relief to stop the measure before scheduled tax-year rules take effect. Legal analysts anticipate that regardless of the initial ruling, the dispute will ultimately return to the Colorado Supreme Court for a definitive constitutional determination.

Primary source: Google News Colorado. Newzly rewrites and structures source reporting for clarity; verify critical details at the original.