Harvard Landscape Designers Propose Water Alternatives to Trump Arch
Harvard landscape architecture students, partnering with The Cultural Landscape Foundation, have unveiled two water-centric concepts for Washington's Memorial Circle, offering low-profile alternatives to a proposed 250-foot triumphal arch.
In this piece
Two Harvard Graduate School of Design students have released conceptual alternatives to a proposed 250-foot triumphal arch at Washington's Memorial Circle.…
Landscape architecture students from the Harvard University Graduate School of Design have released a pair of conceptual counter-proposals to a contested plan for a 250-foot triumphal arch in Washington. Created by students Jeremy Dvorak and Jake Geitner in collaboration with The Cultural Landscape Foundation, the designs envision horizontal, water-based installations at Memorial Circle rather than a towering vertical monument. The release provides a visual alternative to federal proposals that have drawn scrutiny from preservationists and urban planners.
The proposed federal initiative called for erecting a massive classical arch at Memorial Circle, a pivotal roundabout along the ceremonial axis connecting the Lincoln Memorial to Arlington National Cemetery. Proponents envisioned the monumental arch as a grand entrance and commemorative structure. However, civic groups and preservation advocates raised concerns about the scale of the structure, arguing that an imposing arch would disrupt the historic landscape and historic views across the Potomac River.
In response, Dvorak and Geitner developed two concepts under an initiative titled Memorial Avenue: An Irreplaceable Axis of National Memory. Their first concept, framed as a design provocation, preserves the current circular traffic flow around Memorial Circle while transforming the grassy center into an expansive, low-lying reflecting pool. The pool is bordered by a natural stone perimeter inscribed with words emphasizing belonging and unity, allowing visitors to gather without obstructing sightlines toward nearby national landmarks.
The second concept reimagines vehicular circulation by establishing a direct, tree-lined boulevard along a cobblestone axis connecting Arlington Memorial Bridge directly to Memorial Avenue. Flanking this pedestrian-friendly corridor are two circular fountains recessed within low stone mounds. During civic commemorations or bridge closures, the paved surface can be flooded with a thin layer of water to create a continuous reflective sheet, expanding public space temporarily while maintaining day-to-day transit functions.
Rather than rejecting monumentality outright, the designers intended to challenge the traditional reliance on towering classical forms to signify national memory. By relying on horizontal planes, shallow water, and open skies, the alternatives seek to foster quiet reflection instead of visual dominance. Project organizers noted that landscape architecture can evoke deep civic meaning by framing existing surroundings rather than overshadowing them.
The collaboration with The Cultural Landscape Foundation also highlights broader procedural concerns surrounding federal design decisions. Critics and heritage organizations pointed out that the official process for the proposed triumphal arch lacked sufficient public engagement and did not seriously evaluate alternative sites or formats. The student concepts were deliberately introduced into the public sphere to demonstrate the kinds of creative possibilities that emerge when site context and community dialogue are prioritized.
Memorial Circle sits within a carefully calibrated monumental corridor planned in the early twentieth century by the McMillan Commission to symbolize national reconciliation. Preservationists argue that any major intervention at this intersection requires delicate handling to avoid severing the intentional connection between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington House. Landscape advocates maintain that water and open vistas honor the original design intent far more effectively than an oversized classical monument.
While the Harvard proposals remain conceptual exercises rather than formal bids, they have broadened the national debate over how federal public spaces are conceived and commemorated. Legal reviews, agency consultations, and ongoing discussions among preservation authorities will continue to determine the future of Memorial Circle. For now, the student project underscores that public monuments can inspire unity through open, contemplative landscapes rather than imposing stone arches.
Primary source: Google News District of Columbia. Newzly rewrites and structures source reporting for clarity; verify critical details at the original.